Napoli - Milan: Player Ratings
#1
Ok guys. I did this a couple seasons ago and was done by the time December hit. Big Grin I promise I won't do that this time. I will run a weekly spreadsheet and will keep the average. I'll post averages periodically or after each game if that's what people want. In any case, what I'm going to do is open up a players rating thread after each game and just list the players that played in thay game. Whoever wants can just come in and copy-paste the player list and add their rating 0-10. 

I am not thinking of this as a discussion thread but it can be. So if you wanna post comments next to your rating that's fine. I'm just going to pull the rating out though and record it in my spread sheet.

The idea is that at the end of the season we can kind of truly have our best performing players by average score that we gave them.

By the way....you guys don't have to wait for me to open the thread. If someone wants to open a ratings thread in here after a certain game and beats me to it, go right ahead.

Hopefully there is interest in this.
Reply
#2
So here it goes for the Napoli-Milan game:

Donnarumma 
Calabria 
Musacchio 
Romagnoli 
Rodriguez
Biglia
Kessie
Bonaventura
Suso
Borini
Higuain
Laxalt
Bakayoko
Cutrone
Reply
#3
Donnarumma - 6.5
Calabria - 7.5
Musacchio - 7
Romagnoli - 8
Rodriguez - 7
Biglia - 5
Kessie - 6
Bonaventura - 7
Suso - 5.5
Borini - 6.5
Higuain - 7
Laxalt - 6.5
Bakayoko - 6
Cutrone - N/A
Reply
#4
Donnarumma - 6
Calabria - 6.5
Musacchio - 7
Romagnoli - 8
Rodriguez - 6.5
Biglia - 4
Kessie - 6
Bonaventura - 7
Suso - 6.5
Borini - 6.5
Higuain - 6.5
Laxalt - 6.5
Bakayoko - 4.5
Cutrone - N/A
Reply
#5
Donnarumma  6
Calabria            6
Musacchio       6
Romagnoli       7
Rodriguez         6
Biglia                 3
Kessie               6
Bonaventura    6.5
Suso                  5.5
Borini                 5.5
Higuain             6.5
Laxalt                 6
Bakayoko          5.5
Cutrone             N/A ( didnt have much time to do shit )
Reply
#6
Donnarumma 5,5
Calabria 7 
Musacchio 5,5
Romagnoli 7
Rodriguez 6
Biglia 5,5
Kessie 6
Bonaventura 7
Suso 6,5 
Borini 6
Higuain 6
Laxalt 6
Bakayoko 6
Cutrone 6

Some details:
- We could at least got one point if we have a reliable GK and he should try to kick long ball not almost always short pass to other players
- The defense were poor notably Musacchio the worst CB with Biglia did not benefit our defense
- Calabria and Bonaventura deserved 7 due to their great goals while Romagnoli showed a solid performance
"When Costacurta and Maldini won they didn't celebrate much. They were thinking about winning the next game" - Alessandro Nesta
Reply
#7
Donnarumma 4
Calabria 4
Musacchio 3
Romagnoli 6
Rodriguez 5
Biglia 5
Kessie 5
Bonaventura 6.5
Suso 6
Borini 5
Higuain 5.5
Laxalt NA
Bakayoko 3
Cutrone NA

btw wouldn't it be easier for you to create a survey form using whatever free websites which offer free data aggregation or analysis?
Reply
#8
(08-27-2018, 02:41 AM)Siregar Wrote: Donnarumma 5,5
Calabria 7 
Musacchio 5,5
Romagnoli 7
Rodriguez 6
Biglia 5,5
Kessie 6
Bonaventura 7
Suso 6,5 
Borini 6
Higuain 6
Laxalt 6
Bakayoko 6
Cutrone 6

Some details:
- We could at least got one point if we have a reliable GK and he should try to kick long ball not almost always short pass to other players
- The defense were poor notably Musacchio the worst CB with Biglia did not benefit our defense
- Calabria and Bonaventura deserved 7 due to their great goals while Romagnoli showed a solid performance

Passing from the back (starting from GK) was already since last season mainly because of Bonucci. Now I dont think our CBs are ball-playing type, so I hope Gattuso is aware and make changes.
Reply
#9
(08-27-2018, 07:55 AM)edysim Wrote: Passing from the back (starting from GK) was already since last season mainly because of Bonucci. Now I dont think our CBs are ball-playing type, so I hope Gattuso is aware and make changes.

He should have made the changes the moment Bonucci was sold.

Gattuso doing planning and preseason.  Facepalm

[Image: 71ehGT.gif]
Reply
#10
Donnarumma - 6 Couldn't do much i guess
Calabria -6 Apart from scoring goal, and closing down insigne most of the time. After conceded, he had his spirit broken i think
Musacchio - 6 Quite good at first, but then again, who could stand against a barrage of shots.
Romagnoli - 7 Better defender. Very unlucky TBH
Rodriguez - 6 Don't know why gattuso keep building up almost everytime from the left side, with slow wingback.
Biglia - 5 4 One or two nice sliding intercept didnt cover most of his mistake entire game.
Kessie - 6 So-so. Dont know why we got a strong ox like this and doesn't try to attack from longpass. Definitely got outplayed in a short passing game
Bonaventura - 6.5 Sure he created a goal. But then he's quite invisible.
Suso - 5.5 Invisible.
Borini - 6 Apart from his assist. Well, that's the limit of his potential i think
Higuain - 6.5 Trying hard though, falling deep to get the ball, defending, nice lob-through pass. Too bad our Wingback were not offensive like marcelo.
Laxalt - 6 Willing to run. Dribbling too much.
Bakayoko - 6 5.5 Same reason as Kessie. Too much dribbling though
Cutrone - 6 He's a poacher. Couldnt do much if the balls never supplied
Reply