View Full Version : Survey. Do you want Cannavaro to come to Milan and why
come to Milan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Do you support Cannavaro to Come to Milan
1- Yes we want him to come Milan
2- No we don't need him in Milan
3- I don't know
No.
we don't need to elevate our average age and I wouldn't want to make business with Real Madrid.
No.
we don't need to elevate our average age and I wouldn't want to make business with Real Madrid.
It's not a bad choise but i agree with Cris, no more players who are more taht 30....
It's not a bad choise but i agree with Cris, no more players who are more taht 30....
I wouldn't mind if someday when Terry is 31 years old comes to Milan especially when it is a freetransfer move. :grinser:
Nah, he's too old and he wouldn't even come to Milan given that he isn't guaranteed a first team spot.
hany.Egypt
19-07-2007, 05:54
Canna is more than welcome to join us , we need his experiance and he needs our CL experiance as well. Age would not be that serious problem, difenders in common shine after 30+, he is also Italian so he is not going to suffer any kind of home sickness and being a world champion and WPTY are factores that we can't underestemat.IMO this will be awesome singning
hany.Egypt
19-07-2007, 06:03
Nah, he's too old and he wouldn't even come to Milan given that he isn't guaranteed a first team spot
I think that any player that wants to join Milan must understand that there is nothing called a guaranteed first team spot, they should remmeber that Rivaldo and Rui Costa were benched and didn't moan.
Milan is a the Europian Champion and all our players are worldclass ones so being benched is a high possaiblety.
nah
we need fresh good players for that position.
No.
we don't need to elevate our average age and I wouldn't want to make business with Real Madrid.
Fully agree.
Makedonac
19-07-2007, 08:09
We don`t need Cannavaro he is to old. maybe Mexes or Mertesaker(from werder)
Cane1972
19-07-2007, 08:59
How can we say someone is to old when we have much older gentleman on our team who played very well for a long time after the age Cannavarro is?
I say yes as long as the price is right.
hitmannq8
19-07-2007, 11:18
He's the Italian captain, who else in the world can play alongside Nesta better at this time? He has 2-3 more good seasons ahead of him, even if he costs 7.5m pounds he should be brought.
I second that hitmannq8. I watched him play for RM many times last season. This guy is still in a very good shape. Paolo won't be able to play 2 matches in a week, so Canna could fill in his position. Besides Canna and Nesta have been playing together in NT for years so the adaption won't be a problem.
Graeme C
19-07-2007, 12:15
i rather spend the money and get Chiellini. We need a decent LB more than Cannavaro right now.
True. Chiellini is very good, and would be of great benefit to our retaguard.
True. Chiellini is very good, and would be of great benefit to our retaguard.
I prefer both. Oddo, Nesta, Cannavaro/Maldini, Sergi/Chiellini would be great. If Cannavaro plays, we still have 2 big defenders, Nesta and Chiellini.
i rather spend the money and get Chiellini. We need a decent LB more than Cannavaro right now.
chiellini surely is a good player but nowhere near cannavaro's level.
i don't think juve would do business with us and chiellini is more a cd than a lb, much like kaladze.
screw Real Madrid.......whe shall never do business with that Ramon Calmoron
Nah, he's too old and he wouldn't even come to Milan given that he isn't guaranteed a first team spot.
yeeeaaahhhhhhhhhhh, he is too old
yes Chiellini is goog idea Milan should try to bring him he could have good prespective with Milan a and about Canavaro he is great player and capitan of world cup winers italian national but he is to old we have to much old players
At least Canna isn't brazilian... :w221:
Kaka--7thUCL
20-07-2007, 14:28
No.
we don't need to elevate our average age and I wouldn't want to make business with Real Madrid.
It's not elivating our age, if he's replacing Maldini, it's lowering our age..? But I still want him, don't want him. Want him, because he's a good defender, and he's a few younger then Maldini I think :P But I do agree on Chiellini, good player, could use him:) :notlist:
It's not elivating our age, if he's replacing Maldini, it's lowering our age..? But I still want him, don't want him. Want him, because he's a good defender, and he's a few younger then Maldini I think :P But I do agree on Chiellini, good player, could use him:) :notlist:
why compare himwith our oldest defender? It is more prudent to say he will replace Kaladze and/or Bonera. those are the ones that would end up not playing while Maldini will play UCL. Canna won't make Maldini retire and he won't take the same role as him.
I agree with hitmannq8 YES YES YES of course i want him to join milan... Cannavaro is the best deffender in the world , and the best player to play next to Nest coz they been palying together for years in the italian team.... this guy is ROCK he will be 100% a plus for us .
Kaka--7thUCL
20-07-2007, 23:32
Maybe, his age is a factor though.
hany.Egypt
21-07-2007, 07:40
i rather spend the money and get Chiellini. We need a decent LB more than Cannavaro right now.
Milan can buy them both it wont cost that much
... Cannavaro is the best deffender in the world ...
He's not the best defender in the world, if he was then Madrid wouldn't be looking at offers for him.
If the price is right (i.e. around 5-7 million euros) then sure, he could do a good job for a couple of seasons. The first season he'd probably start alongside Nesta, the second season he'd be a good squad option after Maldini retires. I would get Cannavaro and sell Simic.
As hany.Egypt said (and others before him), we could easily buy Chiellini aswell if we wanted to. But if Juve weren't selling to us, there's always Pasqual. There's also no reason why our budget couldn't stretch to Zambrotta as well.
Those 3 additions could give us this group of 9 defenders,
cbs: Bonera, Cannavaro, Kaladze, Maldini, Nesta
fbs: Jankulovski, Oddo, Zambrotta & Chiellini/Pasqual
That's just 1 possibility i guess.
hany.Egypt
21-07-2007, 17:42
we could easily buy Chiellini aswell if we wanted to. But if Juve weren't selling to us,
I dont understand why Italian teams do that, its realy childish, Juve wont sell for Milan, Milan wont sell for Inter, Inter wont sell for Roma, Roma wont sell for Juve.
Things like this would weaken the league, as the major clubs would sell its stars for foriegn ones, so as a result strengthen them and in the end will suffer when they face these teams on the champions league.
He's not the best defender in the world, if he was then Madrid wouldn't be looking at offers for him..
come on man just bcoz he had slow start at Real Madrid, and the new coach had some new calls to take that doesn't mean that Cannavaro isn't the best defender in the world, we are talking about Cannavaro right !!!!
plus the RM management said they won't let him go...
just like Cannavaro said ' some ppl have short memory " :rolleyes:
just like Cannavaro said ' some ppl have short memory " :rolleyes:
So because i don't think he's the best defender in the world, that means i have a short memory?
I never said he wasn't any good, i said he wasn't the best defender in the world, which he isn't.
rosoneri_11
22-07-2007, 06:20
Of course i want Canna at Milan, but i would prefer instead of him a younger DC like Barzagli,Albiol,Chivu,Mexes.
So because i don't think he's the best defender in the world, that means i have a short memory?
I never said he wasn't any good, i said he wasn't the best defender in the world, which he isn't.
At the moment there's no such thing as "The best defender in the world".
There's no way to chose who's better between Terry, Nesta, Cannavaro and 2-3 others.
Cannavaro to Milan depends on 2 very important things :
1. Is Milan really after the veteran player or was it just another rumor ?
2. Will Real sell and is Milan ready to offer as much as Real wants for him ?
As for Chiellini, Manchester City made an offer of 10m euro, which, as reported, is the sum that Juve is asking for him. If Juve rejects this offer then it means that Chiellini was never for sale and it was just another story invented by the English newspapers. If Juve accepts the offer then i guess he won't play in Milan no matter what.
At the moment there's no such thing as "The best defender in the world".
There's no way to chose who's better between Terry, Nesta, Cannavaro and 2-3 others.
Exactly.
As for Chiellini, Manchester City made an offer of 10m euro, which, as reported, is the sum that Juve is asking for him. If Juve rejects this offer then it means that Chiellini was never for sale and it was just another story invented by the English newspapers. If Juve accepts the offer then i guess he won't play in Milan no matter what.
If Juve rejects the offer it might be because Liverpool or another club were/are already in negotiations before Man City arrived.
Kaka--7thUCL
22-07-2007, 17:02
Good post Tony. I'll also take back what I said about his age being a factor, he's kept himself fit, and that's all that matters really, I think he would be a good, not great signing because I still think a young player would be better, no matter how fit he still is, but still a good signing, takes our defense a step up, still, we need a LB. Imagine what a squad we'd have next year... That would be excellent in more then one way too, we'd have the best of both worlds, we'd have best Brazilian attackers, and it just so happens Brazil has the best attack in world, and we'd have mostly, all Italian defense which also happens to be the best in world :D total domination :D
So because i don't think he's the best defender in the world, that means i have a short memory?
I never said he wasn't any good, i said he wasn't the best defender in the world, which he isn't.
hey Jim i'm sorry i didn't mean it don't take it personale... u know what the whole " short memory " thing means ..it refers to all the ppl who said that Cannavaro didn't deserve to be awarded as the player of the year..ect
so he said " some ppl have short memory" ..they forgot the huge acheivements he made , with clubs he palyed for and the nationale team winning the WORLD CUP !!!!
anyway being in his early 30's it doeasn't mean his days is gone he still as good as he ever was, so he IS the best defender of the world.. nuuh not a ward .. ( just try to go along with me here ok) :D
Kaka--7thUCL
22-07-2007, 17:06
I still think Canna would be expensive.. Newais. I just hope Milan rebuilds the squad from what we've lost last year, we still forget we lost Rui Costa aswell, even if he was a sub for most games when he was still a milan player, he was still a great player. We need to buy buy buy:) Currently, I think we need a LB,CB,RF,DM.
It's funny that a lot of the same people who were saying Milan is in bad shape because of old age and this will be a team that we'll be dismembered when this awful, awful season ends (ended up winning CL with "awful" team) are the same ones saying the same thing the second time around and that this "old man" Canna wouldn't be worth the effort of getting. If I'm not mistaken, he won the 2006 Fifa Player of the year award a year ago!! Last I checked, people don't go from great to old in a matter of a year!!! If he's half as good as Maldini is through his honorable 22 years as a rossonero, we can get another excellent 3-4 years out of Canna. Not only is this man guaranteed a job, he is exactly what would make this defense. Unlike Nesta and Maldini, he rarely gets hurt and would take on the same role as he did in the WC as this defense is all Italian. Also, we can finally bench the useless LB Jankulovski and put in Kaladze as Canna would be our LCB. Also, Maldini would come off the bench and giving that he can still put on a perfect 90 minutes, imagine how good he would be off the bench. He'd probably injure a lot less too.
ODDO-----------NESTA----------CANNA--------KALADZE
curry chicken
22-07-2007, 20:26
I would love Cannavaro at Milan. He's not the 'best', but the unspectacular stint at RM is not something I would hold against him (Madrid has a knack for screwing up my fav footballers)...Canna has been class for Juve and who could forget his WC performance (that was only 12 months ago btw)? He can rediscover that form again and of course that nazionale partnership with Nesta. He is a leader and has much experience. We can't go wrong here.
But he's still a Juve faithful and I can see that. If he's going anywhere in Italy it's prolly Turin.
30+ players and Milan are like a match made in heaven. we all know that. :D
I don't understand why would Canna be a Juve faithful, CC
He was in Juve for only 2 years. Yeah, he enjoyed his time there and he never misses a chance to remind everybody of his two years in Juve, but he's a boy from Napoli, who grew up watching Maradona, who loves Napoli more than anything.
He also spent 7 great years in Parma (while he was in Parma he used to attack the refs for helping Juve) and 2 more years in Inter.
If he's a faithful , i'd say he should be a Napoli faithful, even a Parma faithful much more than a Juventino.
I don't doubt he'd like to play again together with Buffon, Del Piero, Camoranesi and Nedved, but he strikes me as a person who would prefer to accept the better money offer and since he won everything, apart from CL, in his career, and he played for all the big teams in Italy apart from Milan, i won't be surprised to see him in red&black.
In this case, regarding the Canna to Milan article, i think it's pure speculation and Milan isn't after Cannavaro, but if Milan's really interested, i'm sure Cannavaro will gladly accept the offer.
I think we've got enough experience at the back, Canna at best is a short term solution, which at this point, i dont think we need. We ought to invest in a "youngish", I dont know, mid 20's defender who can learn from the veterans and be ready to take over in 2 years...
curry chicken
23-07-2007, 00:09
If he's a faithful , i'd say he should be a Napoli faithful, even a Parma faithful much more than a Juventino.
Your right Tony, I can't beleive I forgot about his time at Parma. Maybe I was one more person who got caught up in Canna's wonderful declarations of Juve love, I don't know. He also strikes me as someone who switches clubs for silverware (and who doesn't these days?) and if CL is what he wants then sure, we are very likely to see him at Milan. Honestly I would just like to see him back in Serie A again. Well, back in calcio and NOT playing for Inter that is.
It's funny that a lot of the same people who were saying Milan is in bad shape because of old age and this will be a team that we'll be dismembered when this awful, awful season ends (ended up winning CL with "awful" team) are the same ones saying the same thing the second time around and that this "old man" Canna wouldn't be worth the effort of getting. If I'm not mistaken, he won the 2006 Fifa Player of the year award a year ago!! Last I checked, people don't go from great to old in a matter of a year!!! If he's half as good as Maldini is through his honorable 22 years as a rossonero, we can get another excellent 3-4 years out of Canna. Not only is this man guaranteed a job, he is exactly what would make this defense. Unlike Nesta and Maldini, he rarely gets hurt and would take on the same role as he did in the WC as this defense is all Italian. Also, we can finally bench the useless LB Jankulovski and put in Kaladze as Canna would be our LCB. Also, Maldini would come off the bench and giving that he can still put on a perfect 90 minutes, imagine how good he would be off the bench. He'd probably injure a lot less too.
ODDO-----------NESTA----------CANNA--------KALADZE
Exactly ... :5ok:
Kaka--7thUCL
05-08-2007, 00:03
Lol we don't need Canna, if he comes cheaply which he probably won't we could fit him in beside nesta, but right now we're in desperate need of an lb and a midfielder to destroy inter and take ucl again :)
humanTORCH
05-08-2007, 19:32
first of all let's start by saying no more over 30 players.
secondly he is juventino by heart and let him return to juve.
hany.Egypt
06-08-2007, 03:52
first of all let's start by saying no more over 30 players.
secondly he is juventino by heart and let him return to juve.
Saying that you dont wont any over 30 players in a point that I can understand, but calling Canna a juventino just because he played for juve for only 2 years,well I have to say that I disagree, l he played also for Inter and Parma, so probably like what Tony29 said before he has more loyalty to Parma or Napoli(I heard him on Real Madrid Tv talking about Napoli and how does he feels happy when Napoli win knowing that he said this in an Interview after joinning them, so its almost likely true),and to be honest I dont mind getting a Juventino in our squad so long as he is useful. Infact players nowadays are loyal to money more than any thing else.
Cannavaro started his career in Napoli and was born in Neapel. I don't think we need to discuss his allegiance further than that.
slicknick
06-08-2007, 09:29
Too old...
humanTORCH
06-08-2007, 19:31
Saying that you dont wont any over 30 players in a point that I can understand, but calling Canna a juventino just because he played for juve for only 2 years,well I have to say that I disagree, l he played also for Inter and Parma, so probably like what Tony29 said before he has more loyalty to Parma or Napoli(I heard him on Real Madrid Tv talking about Napoli and how does he feels happy when Napoli win knowing that he said this in an Interview after joinning them, so its almost likely true),and to be honest I dont mind getting a Juventino in our squad so long as he is useful. Infact players nowadays are loyal to money more than any thing else.
basicall what i m saying is let him go back to juve since the rumours of him going back is strong.
once maldini is fit we have kaladze and nesta for the centre back and not to forget bonera. where should we fit him if he comes.
ODDO-----------NESTA----------CANNA--------KALADZE
Oddo---Nesta---Maldini----Janku
is much better combination OR should I say a CL winning combination :bri:
Actually I would love to see him back in Italy but not in ACM, in Juve :5ok:
Its makes Serie-A exciting :grinser:
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.