Player by player.
Dida. Top goalie. I feel this contract negotiation is a problem both for our planning and for Dida's current form. I would keep him unless he really want as big wage as reported.
Kalac. If he somehow manage to get that grease off his fingers and put glue there I would love to have him here. But as it is I feel he could grant our opponents a goal at any moment. i would let him leave and....
Storari. keep Storari. He have been really good the games I seen him play in both last year and this. He looks funny too.
All other keepers in our books. Why are they here? do we still own Abbiati? Coppola, came here and was loanded out. That Greek? is he sold? We possibly own 7 keepers.
Cafu. Thank you for the scudetto, unfortunately our managment managed to keep you longer than both you and I wanted. Is still a solid player, but doesn't give us that little extra we need.
Simic. I think he is solid when playing central defense and a reliable replacement both there and as a right back. for reserves we need players like this IMO.
Bonera. Have been very good in central defense for us, is solid defensivly, but offers very little in offense. Very good player to have around and maybe even someone to be a clear starter in central defense for us.
Nesta. He sure had problems this year, but is still a great, great defender. hopefully he will keep injury free and he will lead our defense next year with Kaladze/Bonera.
Oddo. I honestly wanted Daniel Alves, but Oddo is a really good right back and I can't complain. Will be here for us some years in this position.
Kaladze. Much same as Nesta, he have not performed as well this year as last and had injury problems. but spring last year and they where a rock together.
Serginho. Since last season was possibly his best ever with us I don't see why he could not perform another year until his contract ends. It will come down to how he recovers from the injury of course. Shopping in Brazil for a replacement maybe?
Jankulovski. He have filled in his role well, I honestly wished a bit more of him, but there is nothing wrong with his performances.
Favalli. signed as a backup and truly managed to stay backup ad infinitum. We doesn't really need him, especially since he seems to be out injuried all the time.
Brocchi. He is a good alternative/backup, especially for Gattuso. I am not really in favour of using him together with just Gattuso and/or Ambrosini, but clearly I want him to stay.
Gattuso. I think his performances this year have improved again and I would love for that to continue.
Pirlo. I think it is clear he have not been as good as the last years, he still have some great games and he was awesome in the world cup. what is really wrong? Maybe he just need a prolonged rest, at any rate I would never let him leave if I was the one deciding.
Seedorf. Oh Seedorf, you make me laugh and cry every sunday. when you dribbles a player up the stand and then cross the ball to some player that did not exist. I feel he isn't motivated enough and he doesn't score! He is a very good player, but I am not sure he is as useful as he used to be and he clearly is one of the most frustrating players you could ever look at.
Ambrosini. He have been mostly injuried for years now. The difference this year is that he doesn't come back from injury and head in a goal or something. Its just with expected resignation we see him pulled out for yet another injury.
Gourcuff. showed some real promise in some matches. currently it seems he is out of favour. almost no need to say I want him to stay and develop.
Kaka. While I think last season was his best, this will most likely go down as his worst, clearly a sympton of the whole teamperformance. Like Pirlo he looks in need of a prolonged rest.
Inzaghi. As said, I like his passion and he is one of the few that always looks motivated. But his scoring is clearly down, he is not physically what he was and he commands some huge wages (not that I pay for them). I am not sure whether to keep or not or even what he wants.
Ronaldo. I would say it looks 75/25 in favour him being a performer for us, yes I rate it quite high even with all the warning signs. We all know what he can do and if he do that we can only smile.
Oliveira. clearly he is so far our worst transfer, but things can change fast in football. While he seems to have much talent I would say he doesn't look concentrated. It is also likely heis not at top physical condition as for his injury...
Gilardino. I think we will see him back and he more or less even proved that he is our only striker that is back. Not only have he begun to score, he have layed on his teammates several times.
Borriello. Stop the drugs man!
Youngsters. It is hard to determine if anyone of these have the quality needed to play for our first team next year. Clearly we are not the best club to give them the chance to play. Darmian and Guerci seems to be very talented for their young age, but not ready at all. Willy and Di Gennaro may get a chance or maybe I just hope to much. We also have Antonelli which have played the most of our young ones and Marzoratti who have started plenty of games in Serie A.