The AC Milan player popularity contest!

Kaka 100...

Dida: 6.5
Kalac: 5.5

Cafu: 5.5
Maldini: 6
Kaladze: 5.5
Nesta: 7
Favalli: 5
Oddo: 6
Jankulovski: 5.5
Serginho: 6
Bonera: 5.5
Simic: 5.5

Emerson: 5
Gattuso: 6.5
Ambrosini: 6.5
Pirlo: 8
Seedorf: 6.5
Brocchi: 5.5
Gourcuff: 5.5
Kaká: 7.5

Inzaghi: 6.5
Gilardino: 6
Ronaldo: 6

Someone should compile a short list of non-Milan players and post a similar thread

Dida: 8 (Great saves, Best at Penalty, Leeds Utd and Celtic's fans love him , poor guy, cant be 1st GK, but still one of the best)
Kalac: 5 (Average player)

Cafu: 8 (Back to 2 years ago, he can get an 9, he must accept that he is old)
Maldini: 10 (no need to think)
Kaladze: 7 (Solid, but cant be better)
Nesta: 9 (Considered as the best CD for about ten years, but...)
Favalli: 5
Oddo: 7 (If he was at Milan longer, he can get higher point)
Jankulovski: 6.5
Serginho: 6
Bonera: 6 (He can be better, but now...)
Simic: 5

Emerson: 7 (I have high opinion of him, he needs time)
Gattuso: 8.5 (The warrior of Milan, if his passing, technique is better, he can get 9)
Ambrosini: 7 (Too much injuries...)
Pirlo: 8.5 (The brain of Milan, like Rhino, has weak point, if not, he can get 9, even 9.5)
Seedorf: 7.5 (Last season is best season of him, but we like him, not love him)
Brocchi: 5.5
Gourcuff: 5.5
Kaká: 9.5 (He IS the best player in the world, if he can stand at this place for some years, 10)

Inzaghi: 8 (Most of us love him, I think, he is so unique)
Gilardino: 8 (He makes us depressed many times, but we still wait for him)
Ronaldo: 9 (We need you!)

Originally Posted by rezag

Someone should compile a short list of non-Milan players and post a similar thread

Hey, I like your idea

Dida: 7
Kalac: 6

Cafu: 6
Maldini: 10
Kaladze: 8
Nesta: 9
Favalli: 6
Oddo: 8
Jankulovski: 7
Serginho: 6
Bonera: 6
Simic: 5

Emerson: 6
Gattuso: 9
Ambrosini: 7
Pirlo: 9
Seedorf: 9
Brocchi: 5
Gourcuff: 7
Kaká: 10

Inzaghi: 7
Gilardino: 8
Ronaldo: 8

Dida: 5
Kalac: 4

Cafu: 5
Maldini: 10
Kaladze: 7
Nesta: 9
Favalli: 4
Oddo: 7
Jankulovski: 7
Serginho: 3
Bonera: 7
Simic: 3

Emerson: 4
Gattuso: 9
Ambrosini: 8
Pirlo: 9
Seedorf: 7
Brocchi: 4
Gourcuff: 7
Kaká: 10

Inzaghi: 8
Gilardino: 8
Ronaldo: 6

Maldini: 10 for commiment
Kaka: 10 for consistent & reliable
Gila: 10 for disappointment
Dida: 8.9 for 2003 ucl
Nesta, Gattuso, Ambro, Pirlo, Inzaghi, Seedorf: 9 for being there when it matters most
Emerson: 5 for having the ambition to join us
Kaladze: 7
Ronaldo, Janku & Serginho: 8 for timely intervention and delivery
the others: 3 for providing last minute options and making up the # in training

Dida: 5
Kalac: 3

Cafu: 7
Maldini: 10
Kaladze: 8
Nesta: 9.5
Favalli: 5
Oddo: 8
Jankulovski: 8
Serginho: 7
Bonera: 7
Simic: 6

Emerson: 4
Gattuso: 9.5
Ambrosini: 9
Pirlo: 9.5
Seedorf: 9
Brocchi: 7
Gourcuff: 7
Kaká: 9.5

Inzaghi: 8
Gilardino: 8
Ronaldo: 8

Dida: 7
Kalac: 4

Cafu: 6
Maldini: 10
Kaladze: 4
Nesta: 9
Favalli: 3
Oddo: 6
Jankulovski: 6
Serginho: 6
Bonera: 6
Simic: 1

Emerson: 6
Gattuso: 7
Ambrosini: 8
Pirlo: 8
Seedorf: 8
Brocchi: 4
Gourcuff: 6
Kaká: 10

Inzaghi: 9
Gilardino: 5
Ronaldo: 8


May I add a few other players from the Ancelotti era:
Rui Costa: 10
Sheva: 9
Stam: 8
Oliveira: 4
Tomasson: 7
Pancaro: 6
Costacurta: 7
Rivaldo: 7
Dhorasoo: 7

hitmannq8, no Johann Vogel????

Dida: 5
Kalac: 4

Cafu: 7
Maldini: 10
Kaladze: 4
Nesta: 10
Favalli: 4
Oddo: 6
Jankulovski: 6
Serginho: 5
Bonera: 6
Simic: 2

Emerson: 6
Gattuso: 9
Ambrosini: 7
Pirlo: 10
Seedorf: 8
Brocchi: 4
Gourcuff: 6
Kaká: 10

Inzaghi: 9
Gilardino: 5
Ronaldo: 8

FORZA MILAN!!!!!!!!!!!!

welcome to MM Dalya feel free to make an introductory thread in the Presentations. Also is Dalya your real name?

Dida: 6
Kalac: 4

Cafu: 7
Maldini: 10
Kaladze:9
Nesta: 9
Favalli:6
Oddo: 6.5
Jankulovski: 7
Serginho:6
Bonera: 8
Simic:8

Emerson: 7
Gattuso: 8
Ambrosini:8.5
Pirlo: 10
Seedorf: 9.5
Brocchi: 6
Gourcuff: 10
Kaká: 10

Inzaghi: 7.5
Gilardino: 6
Ronaldo: 6

Dida: 7
Kalac: 4

Cafu: 8
Maldini: 8
Kaladze: 6
Nesta: 8
Favalli: 5
Oddo: 7
Jankulovski: 6
Serginho: 6
Bonera: 5
Simic: 4

Emerson: 6
Gattuso: 8
Ambrosini: 6
Pirlo: 10
Seedorf: 8
Brocchi: 5
Gourcuff: 5
Kaká: 10

Inzaghi: 8
Gilardino: 7
Ronaldo: 8