Crespo to Milan????

Originally Posted by mk18

warro i dont think theres a need for that kind of sarcasm eventhough i agree with you... its her opinion and she presented it with politeness...

Originally Posted by Egoistka

Honey, this conversation again wasnt started by me...you continued this topic perfectly knowing what will be my response. So I guess than you like it. I dont care about Gila, really. Whatever goals he scored were scored in the games where all the rest of the players scored as well..like 5-0, 4-1 and stuff like that. It doesnt show that he is great, sorry! Sure he was in the first team, we paid for him so much money. He wasnt considered as a player for the bench. And Kaka is not an exception. About Rui Costa - I ve never personally liked this guy...he playedgood for Portugal, but never as good for Milan, maybe thats the reason.
PS: if you continue this conversation again, dont get upset, coz you already can predict my reply. OK?

Warro Bantan:
I dont need to be near a person to say what i think about his personality. I dont write a dissertation about it, and dont deny that my opinion can be subjective. Nethertheless it doesnt make me wrong. People can base their judgements on other people's words and behavior, no need to be there with the person from his childhood or smth like that. If you didnt know that - now you know.

well it was nice talking to ya... keep hating gila for whatever stupid reasons u want to, just try not to mention it in half your posts, we got the point already... thank you

Guys,

Whenver we criticize any one or praize any one, it would be really good if you could prove what is so bad or good in that player or the member. this is because MM is a forum with fans having different ideologies so it would be good if we actually say what is wrong with a player and not give reasons like ' I just dont like him.' coz that player might be someone's hero. So just respect every1's view and donot crticize or praise any1 baselessly!

Present some stats to prove ur point and be respectfull. We are talking about players who have committed their lives to this beautiful game so that we can admire them!

Just a request, U r always free to ignore my post!

well something that anoyes me are the members that are always saying what others should do(if they are not mods)......haha

Originally Posted by pa7uel

well something that anoyes me are the members that are always saying what others should do(if they are not mods)......haha

sorry if u dont like it! but i think every1 shud prove their poin!

OK, guys, we all got the point... thanks, let's move on...

Back to the topic... CRESPO...

If he comes back, then who leaves? Amoroso, of course... and we know he has not played at all with Sheva, Gila, and Pippo being in great form... so when would Crespo play?

Originally Posted by Egoistka

Warro Bantan:
I dont need to be near a person to say what i think about his personality. I dont write a dissertation about it, and dont deny that my opinion can be subjective. Nethertheless it doesnt make me wrong. People can base their judgements on other people's words and behavior, no need to be there with the person from his childhood or smth like that. If you didnt know that - now you know.

Yes, indeed, that is a correct statement, no doubt about it, but tell me, how often are those opinions/judgements accurate in the sense that said opinions equate to the truth?

And again, you are voicing your opinion, which is ok, no prob with that...in fact thats why these forums exist..but tell me, what facts are you basing your opinion on?

Show me the quotes, show me the stats, show me something other than your "perceptions" which, IMO are based soley on your dislike for the player, as opposed to measurable evidence.

And for mk18...bro, I didnt think I was impolite...but I apologise if I was...after all, I am a gentleman with class..

SANT, sorry for being off topic, but when I read Egoistka´s post, I felt obligated to reply , since I think her almost constant battering of Gila is ridiculous...or at least her reasons for doing so are. Again, in my humble opinion.

Opinnion which I personally share, but I've decided to overlook some things and concentrate in the fun part...

see my new signature?

Lets all put our toys back in the pram and let things lie

Seriously though, time to move on don't you think ? The relative sides have made their points known (with a high level of politeness from both parties which is to be applauded) and there's no need for anything further to be added ... so lets say take on board what's been said, particularly that there should be some sort of facts to back up opinions and lets all go have a beer and sing karaoke

Originally Posted by Warro Bantan

And for mk18...bro, I didnt think I was impolite...but I apologise if I was...after all, I am a gentleman with class..

no no not at all warro... im sorry maybe i wrote it the wrong way, what i felt when i read ur post is that ur angry and u used aggresive sarcasm, which is typical of u may i add ... just thought u might wanna cool down or atleast reply with calmness she was talking in.

There always seems to be controversy or arguments on these Transfers section. At least this time people were a little more civilised than letting it degenerate into simply swearing at one another.

Anyway, I'm not too keen on Crespo as I don't see why we'd need him. To be more blunt, I don't see a problem with the attack as it is atm.

That's what Pippo thinks on this subject (it's from channel4.com):

The Rossoneri have been linked with possible moves for Chelsea’s Hernan Crespo and Ronaldo of Real Madrid, but Inzaghi believes there is no need for any alterations up front.
“Our attack is envied across Europe by everyone, there is no need for me to give the club any advice on whom to buy,” he said.
Inzaghi is just one of four international forwards playing their trade at the San Siro, seeing as he is accompanied by Andriy Shevchenko, Alberto Gilardino and Marcio Amoroso.
Pippo has a point, doesn't he?

theres no need for addition or alteration. i dont even know why we brought amoruso.
sheva, and gila the main two strikers, and now pippos back into full fitness then he's our alternative!
crespo would either be warmin the bench sat next to pippo, as would ronaldo. theres no need for it

Originally Posted by Warro Bantan

Yes, indeed, that is a correct statement, no doubt about it, but tell me, how often are those opinions/judgements accurate in the sense that said opinions equate to the truth?

And again, you are voicing your opinion, which is ok, no prob with that...in fact thats why these forums exist..but tell me, what facts are you basing your opinion on?

Show me the quotes, show me the stats, show me something other than your "perceptions" which, IMO are based soley on your dislike for the player, as opposed to measurable evidence.

And for mk18...bro, I didnt think I was impolite...but I apologise if I was...after all, I am a gentleman with class..

SANT, sorry for being off topic, but when I read Egoistka´s post, I felt obligated to reply , since I think her almost constant battering of Gila is ridiculous...or at least her reasons for doing so are. Again, in my humble opinion.

OK read this for example:
"At the age of 17 Alberto Gilardino joined Piacenza and scored three goals in 17 Serie A appearances. The following year he joined Verona where he stayed for two seasons making 39 appearances and scoring five times. Not a bad record, but not a true indication of the player he was to become at Parma either.

In his first season with the Gialloblu, Gilardino spent much of his time on the bench as understudy to the prolific pairing of Adriano and Adrian Mutu. The following year he was again meant to be the Brazilian’s understudy, but when Adriano picked up an injury and was subsequently sold back to Inter in January 2004, Gila took centre stage.

By the end of the season Parma’s young hotshot had amassed 23 goals - including four in the last game of the season against Udinese - falling just one behind Capocannoniere Andriy Shevchenko. By the end of the summer Gilardino had also won the Under-21 European Championships and a bronze medal at the Olympics.

Alberto, you exploded on to the scene last year with 23 goals. This term you have already grabbed 16 in 30 games. You must be pleased.
Last season was terrific for me. I may have scored 23 goals but there was also the creation of a group capable of supporting me and helping me to score. At Parma I feel very comfortable playing with my teammates who are always out there to feed me passes.
Which defenders do you find most difficult to come up against?
Alessandro Nesta and Fabio Cannavaro. But also the not so well-known young defenders at the smaller clubs cause me a lot of difficulty because in Italy defenders are all very fit and tactically aware so I can’t name one I can go past with ease.
When did you realise you were a natural-born-striker?
Since I was very little I felt at ease in the box and had an inclination for scoring.
Why didn’t Juventus and Milan pick you when you were a kid yet are now both willing to pay millions for your services?
It was just by chance. I ended up in Piacenza and I cut my teeth there during the days when Simone Inzaghi was the main striker."
(www.channel4)
As you can see from above story about Gila he only shines when the only striker and whole team plays only on him. Thats the explanation of number of scored goals. He says that he "cut his teeth" in Piacenza..why is that? If he is a natural-born-striker and he is mentally strong and stable...why did he say that? Because he is not strong.

Then "Gilardino has scored 17 goals this season, while Inzaghi has hit eight in nine games since returning from a long injury layoff." "Like him or not, Filippo Inzaghi scores goals wherever he goes. From Serie C1’s Leffe to Serie A giants Milan to the Italian national team, he has been rippling the net for the past thirteen years." (http://www.socceropinion.com). I guess Inzaghi's performance speaks for himself...wherever he ve been, whatever he did, he still scored (and didnt cost so much money), bacause he is strong and capable. (Just an example). Gila's doesnt really. For a player bought for 20 million or so it is not impressive performance...You may not agree, but thats my opinion with facts as you asked.


About Crespo - we definately should take this guy. Just think if something happens to one of our strikers and we won't have substitution?! For such price such a good back up plan

Guys, just a liittle reminder: you all know my attitude to Gilardino, if you reply on my posts, including something about Gilardino, I ll reply the way I usually do. I dont talk only about Gilardino, and not true that more than half of my posts is about him. You are so strange: notice (or remember) only my posts that you dont like..and never say (or mention) that I post about smth else. Quite strange...I mean your business, but don generalize if not attantive to what i write...Alright?