Leonardo poll

shegs · 26-04-2010, 04:49

I was going to start this at the end of the season, but since we are mathematically out of the title race, voting might as well start now!

ACMILAN1983 · 26-04-2010, 06:31

I chose good, but not spectacular. I think he's gone well beyond expectations and had we'd remained in the race for the title then I'd say wonderful. However, he has made mistakes and has had some important learning experiences, so overall both him and Milan can consider his performance a good one.

Gabriel489 · 26-04-2010, 06:33

I choose wonderful, only b/c I don't think Milan could have made it to CL or Europe without him.

shegs · 26-04-2010, 08:29

I chose average because of 7-3 against utd, 6-0 against inter, and most importantly, the way he treated Huntelaar.

Lebanese · 26-04-2010, 08:45

let me get this straight, you are doing poll to evaluate Leonardo, because you feel he treated hunteelar unfair?

listen milans problem aint leonardo, he might be a part of the problem but not the problem and to be biased against leonardo just sick and make other posters think low of your oppinion, just before coming with such poll be 100% real and honest then maybe, just maybe other will interact with you.

p.s hunteelar is going to be sold next summer, are you gonna still support milan, i know its stressful privilege, i mean priviledge... and yeah Leonardo is wonderful! without him, we wouldn't make it to Europe.

shegs · 26-04-2010, 10:54

What's so sick about starting a poll on his performance? Or aren't the poll options fair enough? I really wasn't expecting this when i started the poll., i mean its an OPINION poll, don't i have the right to express my personal views as long as they don't break forum rules? Or was i wrong in disclosing my vote?
If i was so 'biased', don't you think i'd have just started a 'do-you-think-H11-was-treated-unfairly' poll?

mzk57 · 26-04-2010, 11:16

Lebanese easy man. Shegs has started a wonderful poll. You support Leonardo, He supports Huntelaar. Its as simple as that

As far as my voting is concerned, well this useless man has to go. And i doubt that B&G would risk to sell the only great player of ACM in summer. Huntelaar is the only genuine international world class starter (for Holland), the rest of ACM players don't have any guaranteed spot in their national teams. I have doubts even over Pirlo for Italy.

If AC Milan wants to move forward, Leonardo needs to be sacked rite now and Guud Hiddink should be appointed as the MAN

Lebanese · 26-04-2010, 11:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by mzk57

Lebanese easy man. Shegs has started a wonderful poll. You support Leonardo, He supports Huntelaar. Its as simple as that

As far as my voting is concerned, well this useless man has to go. And i doubt that B&G would risk to sell the only great player of ACM in summer. Huntelaar is the only genuine international world class starter (for Holland), the rest of ACM players don't have any guaranteed spot in their national teams. I have doubts even over Pirlo for Italy.

If AC Milan wants to move forward, Leonardo needs to be sacked rite now and Guud Hiddink should be appointed as the MAN

i support milan and ppl such as your self support players and blinded by illusions.
let us drop this i am not gonna debate now

Lebanese · 26-04-2010, 11:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by mzk57

Huntelaar is the only genuine international world class starter (for Holland), the rest of ACM players don't have any guaranteed spot in their national teams. I have doubts even over Pirlo for Italy.

buhahahahahahahahahahahhahhahahahahahahahahahahahaha you just made my day.

Reza · 26-04-2010, 15:04

I posted many times about how Carlo banished players after one or two mistakes for example, see Laursen. Either that for whatever reason not trust a player. One season is not enough to judge a player, even if Hunter was playing every game and scoring 30 I wouldn't pass judgment.
About Leo, he has done great in my opinion, it is easy to dream of Lippi and Capello but I don't see any coach winning the scudetto with Favalli and Oddo as his only options for the back. I vote 'Good, but not spectacular.'

Rabia15 · 26-04-2010, 15:50

Leonardo is wonderful! without him, we wouldn't make it to Europe.

Huntelaar just a good poacher...nothing more...

7-2United was due to injury of our players like Nesta and Pato and weakness of our squad...dominated midfield by Park and Fletcher...

inter 4-0...i'd not consider this game cuz i accept Leo made a mistake...playing 4-3-1-2 with Ronaldinho at trequartista,Pirlo deep role and Gattuso and Flamini as box to box players...he played Marek at LB...it was a mistake from Leo...it worked vs Siena yet failed vs inter...

Milan changed starting from Roma 2-1 game...i dont think about the games before that game to judge Leo...

Siregar · 26-04-2010, 16:04

I chose second option, good but not spectacular.

Btw I thought I was in the wrong forum because I saw someone uses other member's post as his signature, something pretty normal in other forum using other member's comment to disrespect that member.

Iggy · 26-04-2010, 18:15

I like the results of this poll so far :-)

Xudong · 26-04-2010, 21:48

I am going to vote for the second item also. I think Leonardo deserves credit where it is due, however, him clearly outfoxed tactically by Ferguson and Mourinho, or even Delio Rossi makes me upset.

edysupriadi · 27-04-2010, 01:14

wonderful! without him, we wouldn't make it to Europe.

View Poll Results: how do you rate Leo's performance this season?
wonderful! without him, we wouldn't make it to Europe.	20	37.74%
Good, but not spectacular.	25	47.17%
An average performance, considering the resources at hand.	4	7.55%
poor, but he was really unlucky with injuries.	1	1.89%
he has to go!!!!!	3	5.66%
Voters: 53. You may not vote on this poll

26-04-2010, 04:49	#1
shegs Registered User Join Date: 05 2009 Location: Lagos, Nigeria. Fave Players: Shevchenko, Ronaldo and Bergkamp.	Leonardo poll I was going to start this at the end of the season, but since we are mathematically out of the title race, voting might as well start now! __________________ Allegri's like a chess player; patient & deep-thinking.... Mourinho is incisive precise and cut-throat. Like a sniper.

26-04-2010, 08:29	#4
shegs Registered User Join Date: 05 2009 Location: Lagos, Nigeria. Fave Players: Shevchenko, Ronaldo and Bergkamp.	I chose average because of 7-3 against utd, 6-0 against inter, and most importantly, the way he treated Huntelaar. __________________ Allegri's like a chess player; patient & deep-thinking.... Mourinho is incisive precise and cut-throat. Like a sniper.

26-04-2010, 10:54	#6
shegs Registered User Join Date: 05 2009 Location: Lagos, Nigeria. Fave Players: Shevchenko, Ronaldo and Bergkamp.	What's so sick about starting a poll on his performance? Or aren't the poll options fair enough? I really wasn't expecting this when i started the poll., i mean its an OPINION poll, don't i have the right to express my personal views as long as they don't break forum rules? Or was i wrong in disclosing my vote? If i was so 'biased', don't you think i'd have just started a 'do-you-think-H11-was-treated-unfairly' poll? __________________ Allegri's like a chess player; patient & deep-thinking.... Mourinho is incisive precise and cut-throat. Like a sniper.

26-04-2010, 11:16	#7
mzk57 Registered User Join Date: 02 2006 Location: Madak Lasht, PK Fave Players: DM10 PM3 AN13 JZ4 GB9 FL8 PN11 WS10 DV7 JDT & KJH	Lebanese easy man. Shegs has started a wonderful poll. You support Leonardo, He supports Huntelaar. Its as simple as that As far as my voting is concerned, well this useless man has to go. And i doubt that B&G would risk to sell the only great player of ACM in summer. Huntelaar is the only genuine international world class starter (for Holland), the rest of ACM players don't have any guaranteed spot in their national teams. I have doubts even over Pirlo for Italy. If AC Milan wants to move forward, Leonardo needs to be sacked rite now and Guud Hiddink should be appointed as the MAN __________________ On 3-7-2010 I thought I would quit watching football, but lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll "WHY so serious?....." Let's put a SMILE on that face! "

26-04-2010, 06:31	#2
ACMILAN1983 Registered User Join Date: 01 2004 Location: England Fave Players: Maldini, Pirlo and rest of Milan	I chose good, but not spectacular. I think he's gone well beyond expectations and had we'd remained in the race for the title then I'd say wonderful. However, he has made mistakes and has had some important learning experiences, so overall both him and Milan can consider his performance a good one.

26-04-2010, 06:33	#3
Gabriel489 Registered User Join Date: 07 2007 Location: Hong Kong Fave Players: Captain Maldini	I choose wonderful, only b/c I don't think Milan could have made it to CL or Europe without him.

26-04-2010, 15:04	#10
Reza Administrator Join Date: 08 2002 Location: Canada Fave Players: Baresi	I posted many times about how Carlo banished players after one or two mistakes for example, see Laursen. Either that for whatever reason not trust a player. One season is not enough to judge a player, even if Hunter was playing every game and scoring 30 I wouldn't pass judgment. About Leo, he has done great in my opinion, it is easy to dream of Lippi and Capello but I don't see any coach winning the scudetto with Favalli and Oddo as his only options for the back. I vote 'Good, but not spectacular.' __________________ aka rezag

26-04-2010, 15:50	#11
Rabia15 Registered User Join Date: 08 2009	Leonardo is wonderful! without him, we wouldn't make it to Europe. Huntelaar just a good poacher...nothing more... 7-2United was due to injury of our players like Nesta and Pato and weakness of our squad...dominated midfield by Park and Fletcher... inter 4-0...i'd not consider this game cuz i accept Leo made a mistake...playing 4-3-1-2 with Ronaldinho at trequartista,Pirlo deep role and Gattuso and Flamini as box to box players...he played Marek at LB...it was a mistake from Leo...it worked vs Siena yet failed vs inter... Milan changed starting from Roma 2-1 game...i dont think about the games before that game to judge Leo...

26-04-2010, 16:04	#12
Siregar Registered User Join Date: 02 2007 Location: Franken Fave Players: Marco Ezio FOSSATI & Simone Andrea GANZ	I chose second option, good but not spectacular. Btw I thought I was in the wrong forum because I saw someone uses other member's post as his signature, something pretty normal in other forum using other member's comment to disrespect that member.

26-04-2010, 18:15	#13
Iggy Registered User Join Date: 11 2004 Location: Norway Fave Players: Marco Van Basten	I like the results of this poll so far :-)

26-04-2010, 21:48	#14
Xudong Registered User Join Date: 10 2000 Location: U.S.	I am going to vote for the second item also. I think Leonardo deserves credit where it is due, however, him clearly outfoxed tactically by Ferguson and Mourinho, or even Delio Rossi makes me upset. __________________ FORZA MILAN

27-04-2010, 01:14	#15
edysupriadi Registered User Join Date: 05 2006 Location: the most peaceful city , JAMBI - INDONESIA Fave Players: Maldini, Nesta, Pippo, Cantona, Kaka	wonderful! without him, we wouldn't make it to Europe.