mzk57

mzk57 · 15-10-2006, 11:57

Hello dear AC Milan fans! A very simple question. Who do u think is the best spot kick taker in last 10-20 years???? (apart form Deigo Maradona)

I think Babriel Batistuta and Roy Makaay have perfect spot kick takers but the best of them all is I think Alan Shearer. The power with which he kicked the ball was amazing, it was almost impossible to stop his kick

. What do u guys say??

kastriot · 15-10-2006, 13:38

I agree, I dont remember seeing him missing a penalty, Pirlo before Istambul was amazing, but....

zlatanov · 15-10-2006, 16:14

I voted for Zidane but would put both Shearer and Zidane up there at the top ... as well as a whole bunch of German Internationals from the past 20 years or so

Acmir^ · 15-10-2006, 17:03

Shearer definitely, i haven't seen him missed a penalty also and he shoots them so powerfull noone could catch that, his penalties simply are a joy to watch

zlatanov · 15-10-2006, 17:46

I think Del Piero should be an option too - he is easily one of the best I have seen from the PK. For every 2-3 years at Juve, thanks to Moggi

, he must be taking more PKs than both Shearer and Zidane took for their entire careers, yet I have seen DP miss only 1-2 of all those PKs ... and his PKs are something quite special too, virtually impossible for the GKs to save.

Graeme C · 16-10-2006, 02:40

Oddo has to get a mension somewhere, he is a pretty good penalty taker and has a good record.. 14/15 taken recently!

rahul.acm · 16-10-2006, 09:32

In recent times Kaka has been doing well too.

Stezagud · 16-10-2006, 10:10

Matt Le Tissier is probably the best i've seen, he was incredibly accurate from 30 yards so 12 yards was easy for him

Zidane and Shearer didnt miss many either and Cantona had a perfect record for years at Utd but then missed a few

A collection of Le Tissier genius:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6OT8m65-hHw

EDIT the penalties are at the end, it says he scored 49 fom 50

Clarence1990 · 17-10-2006, 08:30

Shearer definately has an almost unstoppable kick.
Wesley Sneijder can do it very wel too, but Huntelaar takes the penalty kicks at the moment.
Don't know why though because he already missed 2 this season.

Giovanni · 17-10-2006, 08:56

V Basten scored 24 penalties out of 26 in serie A, even better than Maradona, even though IMO El Pibe de Oro reached the highest level of technique in penalties ever reached. Baggio and Del Piero deserve a mention.

Karim · 17-10-2006, 09:16

Hard to say because basically penalties take good nerves, a good leg, precise one and a bit of luck, Totti has that and that was manifested beautifully in that magnificent Holland game in 2000

Zidane has always been an elegant player also, he showed that in the final among other things

Alan Shearer was a player who made a you feel as if it was nothing.

Ronaldinho power and precision is unbelievable along with his concentration

Pirlo is focused and well places the ball

So many have excelled penalties and you can't just pick only one, but a bunch of them

Dr Milano · 17-10-2006, 09:32

im gonna say van nistelrooy .. although i hate him .. he seems to put it in the net time after time .... its his style them typical goal mouth scrambles and poaching the whole lot of it ...

Jim_UK · 17-10-2006, 10:20

Two of the best penalties i've seen recently have been El Hadj Diouf's for Bolton (though i'm not sure of the opponent, might have been Fulham) and Ballack's for Chelsea.

Milan_Mad · 17-10-2006, 10:34

Kaka must have a record of about 7 out of 7 taken for milan so fingers crossed he keeps that up but by far Ballack is the best penalty taker in football today ive never seen him miss one he even scored one at the world cup standing on one foot

one of the worst ive seen must be van nistelrooy ive seen him miss around 4 for man u 3 for holland and he has already missed one for madrid sorry dr milano you got that totally wrong Sheva is also not the best

other brill takers are
Oddo (though missed one in his last match)
Totti
Chilavert
Del Piero (though seen him miss around 5)
Podolski

Jim_UK · 17-10-2006, 10:53

Van Nistlerooy is hard to judge Milan Mad. For a long period he was exceptional at penalty taking for Man Utd, he just couldn't miss. Especially in his first few seasons there.

I'm sure Steza can give us some facts about it.

View Poll Results: Best spot kick taker?
Gabriel Batistuta	0	0%
Roy Makaay	0	0%
Alan Shearer	5	20.83%
Frank Lampard	0	0%
Zidane	3	12.50%
Ruud Van Nistelrooy	2	8.33%
Ronaldinho	0	0%
Andrea Pirlo	6	25.00%
Rivaldo	0	0%
some other player	8	33.33%
Voters: 24. You may not vote on this poll

15-10-2006, 11:57	#1
mzk57 Registered User Join Date: 02 2006 Location: Madak Lasht, PK Fave Players: DM10 PM3 AN13 JZ4 GB9 FL8 PN11 WS10 DV7 JDT & KJH	Best penalty kick taker u have seen Hello dear AC Milan fans! A very simple question. Who do u think is the best spot kick taker in last 10-20 years???? (apart form Deigo Maradona) I think Babriel Batistuta and Roy Makaay have perfect spot kick takers but the best of them all is I think Alan Shearer. The power with which he kicked the ball was amazing, it was almost impossible to stop his kick. What do u guys say?? __________________ On 3-7-2010 I thought I would quit watching football, but lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll "WHY so serious?....." Let's put a SMILE on that face! "

15-10-2006, 13:38	#2
kastriot Moderator Join Date: 08 2006 Location: Macedonia Fave Players: The one and only MALDINI	I agree, I dont remember seeing him missing a penalty, Pirlo before Istambul was amazing, but.... __________________ Adesso e piu bello vincere - Carlo Pellegati

15-10-2006, 16:14	#3
zlatanov Moderator Join Date: 07 2003 Location: Nowhere near San Siro :( Fave Players: Zinedine Zidane, Genarro Gattuso, Alessandro Nesta	I voted for Zidane but would put both Shearer and Zidane up there at the top ... as well as a whole bunch of German Internationals from the past 20 years or so __________________ "Everyone creates his own luck" - Carlo Ancelotti

15-10-2006, 17:03	#4
Acmir^ Registered User Join Date: 08 2005 Location: Macedonia Fave Players: Maldini, Baresi, Pandev, Van Basten, Kaka	Shearer definitely, i haven't seen him missed a penalty also and he shoots them so powerfull noone could catch that, his penalties simply are a joy to watch __________________ A.C. MILAN & F.K. VARDAR Life ends when you stop Dreaming; Hope ends when you stop Believing; Love ends when you stop Caring; so Dream, Believe and Care. Life is really beautiful!

15-10-2006, 17:46	#5
zlatanov Moderator Join Date: 07 2003 Location: Nowhere near San Siro :( Fave Players: Zinedine Zidane, Genarro Gattuso, Alessandro Nesta	I think Del Piero should be an option too - he is easily one of the best I have seen from the PK. For every 2-3 years at Juve, thanks to Moggi , he must be taking more PKs than both Shearer and Zidane took for their entire careers, yet I have seen DP miss only 1-2 of all those PKs ... and his PKs are something quite special too, virtually impossible for the GKs to save. __________________ "Everyone creates his own luck" - Carlo Ancelotti

16-10-2006, 02:40	#6
Graeme C Moderator Join Date: 05 2005 Location: England Fave Players: Boban, Van Basten, Kaka	Oddo has to get a mension somewhere, he is a pretty good penalty taker and has a good record.. 14/15 taken recently!

16-10-2006, 09:32	#7
rahul.acm Registered User Join Date: 03 2006	In recent times Kaka has been doing well too. __________________ You got a dream, you gotta protect it. People can't do something themselves, they wanna tell you that you can't do it. You want something? Go get it. Period.

16-10-2006, 10:10	#8
Stezagud Registered User Join Date: 06 2003 Location: England Fave Players: Keano (ret), Rooney, Maldini	Matt Le Tissier is probably the best i've seen, he was incredibly accurate from 30 yards so 12 yards was easy for him Zidane and Shearer didnt miss many either and Cantona had a perfect record for years at Utd but then missed a few A collection of Le Tissier genius: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6OT8m65-hHw EDIT the penalties are at the end, it says he scored 49 fom 50 __________________ 'Well, Clive, it's all about the two Ms - movement and positioning.' - Big Ron Last edited by Stezagud; 16-10-2006 at 10:24.

17-10-2006, 08:30	#9
Clarence1990 Registered User Join Date: 04 2006 Location: Holland Fave Players: Seedorf, Shevchenko	Shearer definately has an almost unstoppable kick. Wesley Sneijder can do it very wel too, but Huntelaar takes the penalty kicks at the moment. Don't know why though because he already missed 2 this season.

17-10-2006, 08:56	#10
Giovanni Registered User Join Date: 06 2003 Location: Torino, Italia Fave Players: Gli Immortali/ Gli Invincibili/ I Meravigliosi	V Basten scored 24 penalties out of 26 in serie A, even better than Maradona, even though IMO El Pibe de Oro reached the highest level of technique in penalties ever reached. Baggio and Del Piero deserve a mention.

17-10-2006, 09:16	#11
Karim Registered User Join Date: 07 2006 Location: Cairo, Egypt Fave Players: J.Zanetti, Kaka, Adriano, Recoba, Alex, Ronaldinho	Hard to say because basically penalties take good nerves, a good leg, precise one and a bit of luck, Totti has that and that was manifested beautifully in that magnificent Holland game in 2000 Zidane has always been an elegant player also, he showed that in the final among other things Alan Shearer was a player who made a you feel as if it was nothing. Ronaldinho power and precision is unbelievable along with his concentration Pirlo is focused and well places the ball So many have excelled penalties and you can't just pick only one, but a bunch of them __________________ Treble Winner FC INTERNAZIONALE MILANO 1908

17-10-2006, 09:32	#12
Dr Milano Registered User Join Date: 05 2005 Location: England Fave Players: Zlatan, Pato, Silva, Nesta & Robinho	im gonna say van nistelrooy .. although i hate him .. he seems to put it in the net time after time .... its his style them typical goal mouth scrambles and poaching the whole lot of it ... __________________ Abbiati Sokratis Thiago Nesta Antonini Flamini Pirlo Boateng Pato Ibrahimovic Ronaldinho

17-10-2006, 10:20	#13
Jim_UK Registered User Join Date: 07 2001 Location: England	Two of the best penalties i've seen recently have been El Hadj Diouf's for Bolton (though i'm not sure of the opponent, might have been Fulham) and Ballack's for Chelsea. __________________ ... Is watching you ...

17-10-2006, 10:34	#14
Milan_Mad Registered User Join Date: 02 2006 Location: Cheshire, England Fave Players: Kaka, Maldini, Buffon, Klose!!	Kaka must have a record of about 7 out of 7 taken for milan so fingers crossed he keeps that up but by far Ballack is the best penalty taker in football today ive never seen him miss one he even scored one at the world cup standing on one foot one of the worst ive seen must be van nistelrooy ive seen him miss around 4 for man u 3 for holland and he has already missed one for madrid sorry dr milano you got that totally wrong Sheva is also not the best other brill takers are Oddo (though missed one in his last match) Totti Chilavert Del Piero (though seen him miss around 5) Podolski __________________ Forza Milan

17-10-2006, 10:53	#15
Jim_UK Registered User Join Date: 07 2001 Location: England	Van Nistlerooy is hard to judge Milan Mad. For a long period he was exceptional at penalty taking for Man Utd, he just couldn't miss. Especially in his first few seasons there. I'm sure Steza can give us some facts about it. __________________ ... Is watching you ...

mzk57

kastriot

zlatanov

Acmir^

zlatanov

Graeme C

rahul.acm

Stezagud

Clarence1990

Giovanni

Karim

Dr Milano

Jim_UK

Milan_Mad

Jim_UK